Inclusive overnight packages available 7 days/week start at

---

Returning Shortly!

Love Shack Karaoke invites you to join Friday evenings starting at 9pm.

Story supports original singer songwriters!! Live music is performed Saturdays from 2-5pm (inside the Story Still Tavern during winter months).

Ted Seaman has also returned from his residency at Carnegie Hall with performances in the dining room Friday and Saturday evenings in December.  Thanksgiving marked the start of the  13th year since Ted brought his talents to the Story Inn Dining Room.  

Join us this holiday season with inclusive overnight packages start at $275 weekends, ($225 Sun-TH).  Upgrade the tavern package to 4-course candlelit dining room menu for another $150; $175 for Victorian evenings

The Independence Day Concert and Fireworks Show evolved to include a fundraising dinner in support for the Brown County Community Foundation!

Local suppliers, farmers, and gardeners all chipped in to provide the ingredients.  When placed in the hands of our talented culinary team this fundraising dinner became possible!  

$3,972 was raised from the dinner sales, cash donations, and gift certificate sales.  This amount qualified for a double match from the Lilly Foundation which brought the total fundraising effort to $11,916.   

Special thanks to Lilly, local purveyors, and especially the Brown County Community Foundation for being the tether for so many incredible groups in the community. 

During prohibition, moonshine was bootlegged out of Story such that Sheriff Clarence Moore captured the notorious still on site.  As the story goes, half of the 'evidence' went missing but Story still celebrates the fermentation process.

Enjoy local craft bourbon, live music & entertainment, with arts, crafts, and food vendors Saturday September 27.  With VIP Admission guests receive entrance into the event an hour early with select bottles available to sample.

Leave the children at home for this age 21+ event.

Join us Saturday December 27 for the monthly comedy show!  

Local Legend Brian Smiley hosts  the evening of comedic entertainment featuring Stratton Smith and the anticipated return of Headliner Brent Terhune!

Gates open at 8pm.  Show starts at 8:30

Tickets are $20 at the gate.

Celebrate each Friday and Saturday in December, preceding Christmas, with reservations for our Victorian Candlelit Dinner with live music!  Reservations available 5-9pm.  

Appetizer 

Feta Dip with House made Rosemary, Garlic Crackers

Mulligatawny Soup

Savory Mincedmeat Pies

Salad 

Classic Victorian Watercress Salad with Tarragon Vinaigrette

Spinach Salad with Mustard Vinaigrette

Entree

Sunday Roast(Prime Rib) with Yorkshire Pudding

Baked Dover Sole

Smoked Pork Tenderloin Served with Classic Stuffing

Dijon Encrusted Lamb Chops

Tenderloin of Venison Served with a Balsamic Reduction

Classic 1851 Beef Filet Served with a Medley of Mushrooms

Sides – Choose Two

Cauliflower Casserole, Maple/Bourbon Glazed Tri Carrots, Potato Ragout, French Peas

Desserts

Victorian Christmas Cake

Treacle Tart

Butterscotch and Chocolate Bread Pudding

Inclusive overnight dining room packages start at $450 which include Victorian Candlelit Dinner for two, non-alcoholic beverage, choice of available room in the inn or small cottage, tax, gratuity and continental breakfast.  Upgrade to premium private hot tub cottages add $50, upgrade to Sunday brunch add $50.

Limited space is available for the NYE Murder Mystery Dinner!

The recent murder mystery dinner had such great reviews and sold out so quick we needed to try the interactive production again.  This time, instead of hosting from the Old Mill Banquet Hall, Chef is preparing a four-course menu in the dining room to allow more mingling space.  Guests are also welcome to tour the haunted Blue Lady Room with access  during the event.

Inclusive overnight weekend packages start a to $275 (weekday $225) which include dinner for two from the pub food menu, non-alcoholic beverage, choice of available overnight room, tax, gratuity, and continental breakfast.   Add inclusive dining menu for $150. 

Vintage Baseball is scheduled to return May 16.  Bring the family and enjoy America's Favorite Past Time at Indiana's oldest bed & breakfast!

An afternoon of Vintage Baseball!

Three 5-inning games with 1864, 1869, and 1886 rules

Admission is free!  

Food and concessions available for purchase.  

Games start at 1pm, 2pm, and 3pm ending around 4:30pm.  

Enjoy the 22nd annual Indiana Wine Fair Saturday May 30, 2026 from noon-6pm!  

Sample 1-oz pours from a Story Inn keepsake wine glass, add to your wine cellar with carryout bottles available for purchase, experience the live music all day, and support local arts, crafts, and food vendors.

 More information at: Indianawinefair.com